Read more for all the details on Beauty and the Beast’s Grey Stuff.
Adding another one to the Food from TV Shows and Movies today and we’re exploring Beauty and the Beast’s Grey Stuff!
I have been a huge Disney fan my entire life and to say that I couldn’t contain my excitement to create this, is an understatement. I have a full list of Food from TV Shows and Movies that I’m recreating for basically the next year and a half. This series is just so fun! Have you seen the first post I did for Spongebob’s Jellyfish Sandwich?
I’ve actually seen Grey Stuff done a few different ways but again, the vision of this series isn’t focused on making an intricate interpretation of these dishes but basically, an easy, simple, fun way for everyone to do it! I’m not a professional chef so although I’ve love to put more thought and flavour to these, the thing that matters most to me is that it is yummy!
I re-watched Beauty and the Beast twice last year and if I’m being completely honest, I watched the entire Disney+ library during the whole year of 2020! Disney brings me back to being a little girl and owning all of the VHS and watching it over and over on the couch in my tiny apartment with my mom and dad. I’m thankful for these memories and always love a trip to Disneyland!
What’s your favorite Disney movie? I’d love to know in the comments below!
Hereâs the part in the song Be Our Guest from Beauty and the Beast where the Grey Stuff is featured (0:35)!
Watch the inspiration behind Beauty and the Beast’s Grey Stuff:
I immediately knew what I was going to do for this Beauty and the Beast’s Grey Stuff recipe as soon as I watched the video again and I was so nervous to make the sugar cookies from scratch!
If you have been following the blog for a while you’d know that baking and I don’t have the most strong relationship yet. We’re working on it but it’s definitely a journey!
The Best Sugar Cookie Recipe I followed to a Tee is one from In Katrina’s Kitchen!
I swear, I’ve never baked more perfect cookies than these. I shocked myself and started jumping for joy at 11 pm because they turned out amazing! This will be the sugar cookie recipe I follow forever!
The actual grey stuff is actually just pudding, cool whip and Oreos and everything just tasted so perfect!
Would you try this pretty Beauty and the Beast’s Grey Stuff dessert?!
PIN Beauty and the Beast’s Grey Stuff FOR LATER:
This Beauty and the Beast’s Grey Stuff recipe is accompanied by a YouTube Tutorial. If you havenât subscribed to my channel on YouTube, donât forget to!
HERE IS HOW TO MAKE Beauty and the Beast’s Grey Stuff:
WHERE CAN I FIND THESE INGREDIENTS?
Everything can be found at your local grocery store. I’m not that sure if Cool Whip can be found around the world but in North America, it’s a very popular, easy-to-use whipped topping for desserts! I believe the Vanilla Pudding mix can be found in most stores around the world, it may just be a different brand based on your location. I used Jell-O Vanilla Pudding Mix but there are so many options on the shelf, I’m certain pretty much everything works!
For the sugar cookies, you’ll need basic baking ingredients such as flour, butter, baking powder, vanilla extract, salt, almond extract, eggs etc. Hopefully, you’ll have some at home but if not, these are pretty Standard things to find at the store!
WHAT ARE THE INGREDIENTS?
For the Sugar Cookies:
- Butter
- White Sugar
- Vanilla Extract
- Almond Extract
- Egg
- Baking Powder
- Salt
- Flour
For the Grey Stuff Topping:
- Cool Whip
- Vanilla Pudding Mix
- Milk
- Crushed Oreos
- Black Gel Food Colouring (Optional)
WHAT EQUIPMENT DO I NEED?
The main thing I highly recommend that you have for this recipe is definitely a scallop or flower-shaped cookie cutter! I highly recommend this because it sets the whole experience together! I picked mine up from my grocery store for $2! This recipe will require dry and wet ingredients in two separate bowls. Youâll need a cookie sheet lined with parchment paper and of course, an oven! Youâll need a Spatula to mix as well as a rolling pin. You can slab on the grey stuff topping or you can pipe it on with a large piping tip and piping bags.
CAN I SUB ANYTHING OUT?
Nothing at all! DON’T DO IT. This is soooo perfect and exactly what I imagine Belle would enjoy! This surprisingly wasn’t that sweet either which is a bonus as I was able to stuff my face in them.
In all seriousness, I used Oat Milk for this recipe so if you want to sub that out, you definitely can! Any milk you prefer will do great!
For the Cool Whip, you can opt that out and use fresh whipped cream which is my fav but I took the easy way out with this one!
The Oreos can be subbed for anything off brand too. Any chocolate cookie you can crush works!
WHAT DOES IT TASTE LIKE?
I loved this one and was super worried that it might be too sweet but it’s definitely not the case! It tastes like pudding and cookies which is very delicious. The sugar cookies are quite soft so the overall texture of everything is pleasant.
ANY OTHER NOTES?
No additional notes for Beauty and the Beast’s Grey Stuff! Just make sure to turn on Be Our Guest and listen to the song while you eat them OR watch the full movie and enjoy these treats with coffee or tea! Such a fun experience especially if you have little kiddos in your life who love Beauty and the Beast!
Beauty and the Beast’s Grey Stuff
Equipment
- Oven
Ingredients
Sugar Cookies
- 1 Cup Unsalted Softened Butter
- 1 Cup White Sugar
- 1 Tsp Vanilla Extract
- 1/2 Tsp Almond Extract
- 1 Egg
- 2 Tsp Baking Powder
- 1/2 Tsp Salt
- 3 Cups All Purpose Flour
Grey Stuff Topping
- 8-10 Crushed Oreos
- 1 Package Vanilla Instant Pudding Mix
- 1 Cup Cold Milk
- 1 1/2 Cup Cool Whip
- Black Gel Food Colouring (Optional)
Instructions
Sugar Cookies
- Preheat oven to 350F and lined your cookie sheets with parchment paper.
- In a bowl, using a stand or hand mix, cream butter and white sugar until smooth for about 3-4 minutes.
- Add in the vanilla and almond extract as well as the egg and beat together for another minute or so.
- In a seperate bowl, add in your flour, baking powder, and salt.
- Scoop in about a cup of the dry ingredients at a time into the wet ingredients until everything is combined. The dough will be crumbly.
- On a clean and floured surface, knead your sugar cookie dough together until you're able to shape into a ball.
- Split the dough in half and roll out the first chunk. Using a flower or scallop cookie cutter, start shaping your cookies and place on baking sheet.
- Bake for 6-8 minutes and let the cookies cool completely on a cookie rack.
Grey Stuff Topping
- In a bowl, add in your one package of Vanilla Instant Mix and Cold Milk.
- Whisk together til the consistency thickens and fold in your Cool Whip and 3/4 of the Crushed Oreos.
- At this point, it will be a tad grey but if you want to intensify the colour, you can add in Black Gel Food Coloring. I just stuck a tooth in there a few times.
- Add mixture into piping bag with whatever piping tip you hvae and let chill for 10 minutes.
- Pipe the mixture onto the top of the cookie and garnish with the rest of the Crushed Oreo Cookies.
- Serve and enjoy!
I loved making Beauty and the Beast’s Grey Stuff so much and I hope you enjoyed reading it and also hopefully get a chance to make it one day!
All Disney movies, princesses especially, have a special place in my heart and I can’t wait to one day pass this joy to my little kiddos in the future so they can feel the magical moments I felt.
Belle isn’t my favorite Princess, Ariel is so you’ll just have to wait and see what I come up with for Ariel!
Who is your favorite Disney Princess? Let me know below!
Xo,
Lynn
This blog post is all the details on Beauty and the Beast’s Grey Stuff.
P.S: If you havenât read my most recent post, click here!
PIN Beauty and the Beast’s Grey Stuff FOR LATER:
Catch these delicious recipes:
Great recipe, I love this movie. This is a very original recipe
Thanks for sharing
Me too! Thank you so much x
Oh how fun! I think I’d be more willing to eat this than the Sponge Bob recipe hehe. It sounds really good! You had me at crushed Oreos đ
HAHA! Yes, the Spongebob recipe was questionable! Thanks, so much for reading, Allison! xx
Oh my god this is such a cute post! Beauty and the Beast is one of my faves. I never thought about what the grey stuff might be but this looks really yummy!
I love this post! I’m a big fan of Disney films. Aries is my absolute favourite princess although I do have a soft spot for rapunzel! Such a great idea to create recipes from the films! I look forward to seeing what else you come up with!
Both great movies! I have watched Tangled more than the number of fingers and toes I have hahaha Thanks for reading xx
Right! Thanks so much for reading, Jenny xx
Oh we love Beauty and the Beast!! Honestly, this looks delicious! Anything that involves sugar cookies and is Disney related is a huge yes to me! I really like Ariel, but my favourite must be Merida or Rapunzel x
A huge yes for me as well! I love Tangled and Brave too! I need to rewatch Brave! Thanks so much for reading, Cristina x
When I saw Beauty and the Beast I clicked faster than Lumiere could say “Be our guest!”. This post is so cute and I definitely need to try out that recipe soon; it looks amazing!!
Haha! Thanks so much! I had so much fun making these! xx
Ofc! I can’t wait to try it myself; it looks really fun xx
This is so cute! I remember watching all the Disney movies when I was little and then watching them all with my kids. Beauty and the Beast was one of my daughters favourites. We must have watched it a millions times. I will definitely have to make these for her. Thanks for sharing this adorable recipe! I can’t wait to see what you do next! xx
Aw, that is super sweet! I can’t wait to pass this on too! Thanks so much for reading, Tiffany x
Beauty and the beast is my fave and I love how you’ve brought this recipe to life xx
Thank you so much for reading! It’s super fun xx
Cool whip and crushed oreos? I’m in! Seriously though, this was such a cute post idea, and you’re kind of just encouraging me to get a Disney+ subscription. Somehow I’ve managed to go without it all this time, but… ??ââïž
Yes! So worth it to me. I’m kinda over Netflix and have been just using Disney + this year. Rewatching everything on Disney has been super nostalgic! Thanks for reading, Allison! x
Great post! I love this idea, and I’ve always been a big fan of Disney! Thank you for sharing, these are adorable and I can’t wait to see more x
Aw, thank you so much for commenting, Eleanor! xx
Oh this is so fun! I’m a bit Ratatouille fan so I’ll have to find some yummy pasta dishes! Xx
Ooh! I’ll need to rewatch Ratatouille! Thank you for stopping by xx
This recipe is interesting. It is something new to me. Thank you for sharing.
Thank you so much for commenting, Fadima! x
this is a very interesting post! the cookies looks delicious
thank you for sharing the recipe
i hope you have a great weekend!
Thanks so much, babe! You have an awesome weekend too! xx
The grey stuff really is delicious! A childhood question finally answered, haha.
Haha! I love that! Thanks for reading, Jenna! xx
This is such a cute idea. I love beauty and the beast. Such a good movie. The cookies look so delicious.
Thanks so much for stopping by! x
Looks so fun! I’m loving this series of you recreating food!
Molly xx
https://volumesofbeauty.com
Thanks for stopping by, Molly! x
As in ‘The Grey Stuff’ is a thing? How long have we been missing out? Smiles!
Haha! Yes! It’s supposed to be savoury but I see it more as a sweet dessert! Thank you for reading xx
I genuinely thought the Gray stuff was caviar as the live action uses it haha! These sound so sweet!
I actually haven’t seen the live-action of really any Disney remakes haha! I could totally see that since it was a plate of Hors d’oeuvres after all! I will take any excuse to make something in dessert! Thanks for reading, Sarah! x
These look delicious Lynn! The grey stuff is so delicious, it’s wonderful to know I can do an at home version now – thanks for sharing.
Thank you so much!! I am so guilty of eating the whole plate myself hahah x
These cookies look delicious and I love the Beauty and the Beast theme behind it! x
Lucy | http://www.lucymary.co.uk
Right! This series is so fun. Thanks for reading lovely x
I’ve not seen this before but it sounds interesting.
Thank you so much for stopping by! x
These are so fun! I love this series of recipes. I love me some Oreos so I will definitely be trying this, maybe with my daughter! My favorite Disney princess is Cinderella, although Ariel is a close second. xx
A big yes to Oreos for me too! This would be fun to make with your daughter for sure! Can’t wait to have little kiddos to do this with as well! Thanks for commenting, Heidi xx
Ooo these look good and I love that they are inspired by Beauty and the Beast! My niece would love these!
When I was younger my favourite Disney princess was pocahontas. More modern day, I love Moana haha!
Thanks for sharing Lynn!
Aimsy xoxo
Aimsyâs Antics
Yes! Moana!! Can’t tell you how many times I’ve watched it. Thank you for commenting, Aimsy! x
I also like Beauty and Beast and these cookies look very delicious. Thank you for sharing recipe.
http://www.exclusivebeautydiary.com
Thank you so much for stopping by! x
LOVE the creativity in this recipe! I always loved this story, but I really only wanted the library. ??? Thanks for sharing!
Thanks so much for reading this, Aspen! x
This is fun and these cookies look delish! You are so talented!
xoxo
Lovely
http://www.mynameislovely.com
Thanks so much, Lovely! x
This is so lovely. I can imagine doing this for a little one’s birthday party and making it feel really posh!
Rosie
Isn’t it the cutest! Thanks so much for reading, Rosie! x
Beauty and the beast is my all-time fave Disney film! I also love Lady and the tramp because of the memories of watching on a VHS tape with my mum in the evenings. These cookies look so good ? I’m loving this series xx
Totally!! I loved the VHS tape era! Thank you for commenting, Caroline xx You’re a sweetie!